What is right of first refusal?

Time to read min

Quick insight

The right of first refusal (ROFR) is a legal provision in real estate that gives a prioritized, interested party the exclusive opportunity to buy or lease a property before the owner can negotiate with other prospective buyers or tenants.
ROFR can be used in various scenarios such as lease agreements, partnerships, real estate development, family properties and commercial leases.
To secure a right of first refusal, it is essential to identify the asset, discuss and outline terms with the owner, work with a real estate attorney to create a formal document and maintain open communication about intentions to exercise the ROFR.

The right of first refusal (ROFR) is an exciting concept in real estate that puts you in the driver’s seat when it comes to property decisions. Imagine having the exclusive first chance to buy or lease a property you adore before anyone else gets to take a tour. This legal provision acts like a VIP pass, ensuring that if the owner decides to sell or rent, you get the first opportunity to make an offer. Whether you’re eyeing a charming home or a prime commercial space, understanding the right of refusal can open doors to incredible opportunities. Let’s dive into how this works!

What is right for first refusal?

In real estate, the ROFR is a clause in a contract that gives a prioritized, interested party the right to make the first offer on a house before the owner can negotiate with other prospective buyers. This right is often included in lease agreements or contracts and is designed to protect the interests of the holder, allowing them to secure a property they desire. Here are a few key points to consider:

Exclusive opportunity: The holder gets the first chance to buy or lease the property.
Notification requirement: The property owner must inform the holder before seeking other buyers or tenants.
Protective measure: It safeguards the interests of the holder in a competitive market.
Common uses: Often included in lease agreements, partnership contracts or real estate deals.

When a right of first refusal might be used

A right of refusal may be used in several scenarios:

Lease agreements: Tenants can secure the first chance to buy if the landlord decides to sell.
Partnerships: Partners can buy out a share before it’s offered to others.
Real estate development: Developers can ensure future opportunities on land they’re interested in.
Family properties: Family members can keep property within the family by having the first option to buy.
Commercial leases: Businesses can expand into adjacent spaces by having the right to refuse other offers.

These situations show how ROFR can provide security and control in real estate and business dealings.

How to get a right of first refusal

To secure a right of first refusal, it’s important to identify the asset. Decide on the property or business interest you want. Next, discuss and outline terms with the owner including notification procedures. Work with a real estate attorney to create a formal document specifying conditions and response time. Ensure the agreement complies with relevant laws and regulations. Both parties should sign the contract to make it legally binding and maintain open communication about intentions to exercise the ROFR.

Right of first refusal vs. right of first offer

The right of first refusal and the right of first offer (ROFO) are both contractual agreements that give one party a preferential position regarding a potential sale, but they operate differently:

Right of first refusal

Mechanism: The holder can purchase the asset on the same terms or a pre-determined price that the owner has agreed upon with a third party.
Trigger: Activated when the owner decides to sell and has received an offer from another buyer.
Outcome: The holder can match the offer or decline, allowing the owner to proceed with the third party if the holder declines.

Right of first offer

Mechanism: The holder gets the first opportunity to negotiate and make an offer before the owner can offer the asset to others.
Trigger: Activated when the owner intends to sell but before any offers are received.
Outcome: If the holder’s offer is acceptable, the sale occurs. If not, the owner can then seek offers from other buyers.

The key differences are timing and negotiation. ROFR comes into play after an offer is received, while ROFO occurs before any offers are made. ROFO allows for initial negotiation, whereas ROFR requires matching an existing offer.

Pros and cons of right of first refusal

Let’s explore the potential advantages and disadvantages of the right of first refusal and its implications in real estate transactions.

Pros of right of first refusal for the owner

Potential buyer pool: The ROFR can attract serious interest from the holder, ensuring they have a motivated buyer when they decide to sell.
Price stability: It may stabilize the property value, as the holder is likely to make a competitive offer.
Control over sales process: The owner can set terms with the holder, potentially simplifying negotiations.

Cons of right of first refusal for the owner

Limited marketability: The presence of a ROFR can deter other potential buyers, making it harder to sell the property.
Time constraints: The owner may face delays while waiting for the holder to decide whether to exercise their right.
Potential for lower offers: The holder might only offer a price they perceive as fair, which could be less than market value.

Pros of right of first refusal for the holder

Opportunity for ownership: The holder has the first chance to purchase, potentially securing a valuable asset.
Security in investment: It provides a safety net, allowing the holder to maintain control over their living or business situation.
Negotiation leverage: The holder may negotiate better terms knowing they have priority over other potential buyers.

Cons of right of first refusal for the holder

Financial pressure: The holder must be financially prepared to act quickly if they want to exercise their right.
Potential for discontent: If the holder does not exercise the right, they may feel frustrated or regretful about missing the opportunity.
Complicated decision-making: Weighing the benefits of exercising the ROFR versus other investment opportunities can lead to challenging decisions.

In summary

The right of first refusal is a powerful tool in real estate that can protect both buyers and tenants. It allows you to secure opportunities before others, fostering a sense of control in transactions. It’s important to understand the terms, duration and enforceability to avoid potential pitfalls. Whether you’re a landlord or a tenant, clear communication and adherence to the agreement are key for a successful relationship. It's important to seek guidance from a home lending advisor or real estate attorney to help you navigate this process.

Right of first refusal FAQs

How to get out of a right of first refusal?

To terminate or modify a ROFR, you typically need to negotiate with the other party. This may involve mutual consent or specific provisions outlined in the original agreement.

How long does a right of first refusal last?

The duration of a ROFR is generally specified in the contract. It can last for a set period or until certain conditions are met.

Can a landlord violate a right of first refusal?

Yes, if a landlord sells or leases the property without offering the tenant their ROFR, it could be considered a violation of the agreement.

Is the right of first refusal enforceable?

Yes, ROFRs are generally enforceable as long as they are clearly defined in a written agreement.

What happens if you violate right of first refusal?

Violating a ROFR could lead to legal disputes, and the affected party may seek damages or enforcement of the agreement.

What is the difference between option to purchase and right of first refusal?

An option to purchase grants the buyer the right to buy the property at a predetermined price, while a ROFR allows the holder the opportunity to purchase before the owner sells to someone else.

What triggers a right of first refusal?

Generally, a ROFR is triggered when the property owner receives a bona fide offer from a third party or decides to sell the property.